The 27th anniversary of the death of this titan of Jazz occurred a little over a month ago, and to this day, words simply cannot describe the depth of his artistry. His music has always been the best representation, as evidenced by a video clip I recently was made aware of, recorded a month before his death in 1980. The composition is entitled “Your Story.â€
Listening to this for the first time, I was reminded of my astonishment during my initial viewing of Ken Burns’ landmark documentary on Jazz, in which Evans, though clearly in the Top 10 all-time in terms of musical influence, was only mentioned for his role as a sideman on Miles Davis’ “Kind Of Blue†album. I know this is the best-selling jazz album ever, but one only has to listen to the interview Bill Evans gave after the 1980 concert to understand the depth to which this album, even in 1980, had become a musical cliché.
And since the kindly Rev recently mentioned Stan Kenton, Burns also ignored the tremendous contributions of both Stan and Woody Herman to the big band evolution of jazz. Why would he do this? Mostly due to the fatal flaw of using Wynton Marsalis as his primary musical consultant, a man whose arrogance is only exceeded by his ignorance of the essence of this music. The other fatal flaw is attributable to Burns himself, who chose to frame his entire film around the same theme he used for his films on the Civil War and Baseball: Race.
Ironically, it was Race that led Burns to concoct the fictional story of Jazz essentially dying after the passings of Armstrong and Ellington, only to be heroically resuscitated in the early 1980’s by . . . wait for it . . . Wynton Marsalis. This account allowed Burns to ignore every prominent jazz artist of the last forty years, because his major theme no longer applied nearly as powerfully as it did describing the heydays of the music’s early pioneers. Meanwhile, the Michael Brecker’s, the Pat Metheny’s, and the Maria Schneider’s didn’t exist in the highly ethnocentric world created for Burns by Marsalis.
But this is not the real reason I chose to create this blog entry. Getting back to Evans, I am reminded of the huge differences even among jazz fans concerning what elements are linked to a favorable listening impression. I have met some people with encyclopedic knowledge of Jazz, who only respond to those performers who demonstrate either an unearthly facility on their instrument, or play their instrument with a mechanical perfection. Others enjoy being hit over the head with their Jazz, responding to anything that is high, fast and loud. Still others have a myopic sense as to what is truly Jazz, concentrating their affections on one facet of the evolution, and ignoring all others. And finally, and most sadly, there are those who are convinced that what they enjoy is Jazz, but have been duped by the often financially successful genre known as Smooth Jazz.
There can be no dispute that Bill Evans was magnificent. His completely original style of playing and composing, along with his no-nonsense commitment to exploring the maximum potential for expression in Jazz, clearly make him a member of a club Duke Ellington was a charter member of: Beyond Category.
For more info on all things Bill Evans, here’s a link to a suitable repository on the web.